ARGUMENT ANALYSIS Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words

ARGUMENT ANALYSIS - Essay Example Initially, Kamenetz rationalized that legal age requirements must be flexible depending on circumstances, valid endeavors and supplemented with specifically identified requirements. As averred, â€Å"legal age requirements should never stand alone. They should be flexible and pragmatic and paired with educational and cognitive requirements for the exercise of legal maturity† (Kamenetz par. 4). Using cognitive faculties, the author progressed by using logical appeals through citing credible contemporary practices. One of the valid supports presented legal regulations in driving. As disclosed, driving laws epitomized the best model for justifying that an early orientation to driving classes would result in more positive outcomes, especially in terms of lesser fatal crashes. The statistics cited was sourced from the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety which conducted a study which revealed that â€Å"the most restrictive of these programs are associated with a 38 percent reduction in fatal crashes among the youngest drivers† (Kamenetz par. 5). Using parallelism, the author expounded the early driving permit example to potentially include its application to voting through a proposed early voting permit. As suggested, a preliminary civics course could be used as a standard requirement for passing to qualify a young citizen to enforce the right to vote. The author further explored the applicability to empowering youngsters to expand the rights, not only to voting, but to include areas such as drinking, marriage, and responsible use of credit cards to manage financial obligations. The author indicated that â€Å"in reality, this is already when most people have their first jobs, their first drinks and their sexual initiations. The law ought to empower young people to negotiate these transitions openly, not furtively† (Kamenetz par. 7). However, the author failed to provide any counter-arguments to balance the proposed expansion of empowering teenage rs to these activities. The strengths of the author in supporting the contentions lie in the effective selection of examples which were effectively backed by reliable sources. The essay was structured in a clear and logical manner that flowed well. The tone was appropriate and formal to effectively manifest professionalism in treating the advocated lowering of voting age. There was no eminent overly expressed intention to use emotional appeal and therefore, the strategy of using logical appeal enhanced the author’s credibility in promoting the advocated cause. One noted weakness was the failure of the author to effectively reference the cited sources (such as the study published by the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety). Moreover, there was a cited statistical figure at the concluding paragraph which was not appropriately cited: â€Å"Demographically, those over 85 are our fastest-growing group. By 2020, the entire nation will be about as silver-haired as Florida is todayâ⠂¬  (Kamenetz par. 11). These statements need citations to enable readers to verify their authenticity and reliability. Further, the concluding portion focused more on the threat or risks posed by the aging population that did not tie at all on the author’s thesis statement. There was lack of expounding support for recommending young teenagers at the earliest age of 16 to vote by either providing advantages and also balancing the

Merketing research strategy for a case study Paper

Merketing strategy for a case study - Research Paper Example This matter has been made worse by a section of the media, which has published derogatory article showing that the event should not be sponsored by the government. Another section of the public argues that the event benefits commercial businesses in the Gold Coast, and hence it is not worth government sponsorship. The following report is prepared with the aim of justifying the current financial commitment for the event. Table of Contents Problem statement 4 Background 4 Management Decision Problems 4 Marketing Research Problem (MRP) questions/statement 5 Research objectives 5 Proposed mixed method to address MRP 5 The proposed Research design 5 Data collection instruments – questionnaire 7 Sampling plan, data collection procedures and data analysis 8 Key limitation of the study design 10 Independent-samples t-tests 10 Analysis of variance (ANOVA) 12 Bivariate correlation coefficient matrix 14 References 15 PART A Problem statement Background ‘Schoolies’ week is a major tourism attraction event, which takes place annually at the Gold Coast, Australia. The event, which attracts many sponsors and participants, is usually attended by students who have completed their Year 12 (the final year at high school). ... 4. How can the negative perception of the members of the community against ‘Schoolies’ be changed? 5. What actions can be taken to curb the media’s negative publicity of the ‘Schoolies’? 6. What information can be gathered to justify the financial commitments of ‘Schoolies’? 7. What actions can be taken to show the locals that ‘Schoolies’ is a worthy public project? Justification Since the ‘Schoolies’ events were started in 1975, many negative behaviors have resulted in the events’ negative publicity, and actions needs to be taken to address this problem, if the event is going to get public good will. This negative publicity has been as a result of negative behaviors, such as drunkenness, which cause civil disturbances in the main street. As such, the actions that should be undertaken to rescue the good name of this project, should focus on changing the behavior of the students who participate, because thi s is the root cause of problems. Despite its perceived social economic benefits, the role of the state government as a financier of the event has faced many hurdles because some groups, including the members of the opposition have argued that the event is largely benefiting the private sector such as the hotels along the beach, hence not worth the sponsorship. This calls for a deliberate action by the government to ensure that the real benefit of the event to the members of the public is evident, to justify its financial commitment. Marketing Research Problem (MRP) questions/statement 1. Why do the media and the public consider ‘Schoolies’ as a negative project that is not worthy commitment of public resources? 2. Why do the youth who attend the